Sam Goldsmith

A blog about music, travel, writing, photography, politics, Istanbul, teaching, life, and everything in between
Showing posts with label LGBT Rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LGBT Rights. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

If I Were Chief Justice Roberts...

Don't get me wrong, today was a wonderful day for marriage equality. DOMA was rightly struck down as unconstitutional, and we got perhaps the best ruling on Prop 8 we could expect from a conservative court such as this (the 5-4 majority on Prop 8 was the oddest combination of justices, too).

Now people are celebrating, and for good cause, but there's something unsettling about the people out there who are celebrating Anthony Kennedy's role in the DOMA decision. Yes, he was key vote in overturning DOMA. He was also the key vote in yesterday's ruling gutting the Voting Rights Act, a disappointing ruling to say the least.

If I were Chief Justice Roberts and wanted to help out the Republican Party as much as I could this court session, a session taking place not long after an election landslide victory for my opponents, I would prioritize my major issues. The major docket issues this June, or at least the ones that proved to attract the most public attention, were: affirmative action, voting rights, and marriage equality. If Chief Justice Roberts could chose just one of these issues to claim as a victory, on behalf of the Republican Party, which would it be?

Voting rights, without a doubt. It would grant the Republican Party a great deal of lasting political power. The other two issues could be sacrificed without the loss of Republican power. And let's not forget that Prop 8 and affirmative action were decided on very narrow grounds that don't change much at all. Only DOMA and the Voting Rights Act were irrevocably changed.

And, with a stroke of political genius, if I were the Chief Justice I would release the decision on marriage equality last, knowing it would eclipse the Voting Rights Act decision's public importance (save the best for last) and wipe it from many memories.

After the Voting Rights Act was hobbled yesterday, many people pointed out that the decision left room for Congress to enact similar legislation using modern-day statistics. Indeed, the Supreme Court gave Congress clear instructions on how to refashion the law in a manner in harmony with the Constitution. Yesterday there was a sizable amount of support for this sort of solution and it looked as if an effort might be made in Congress to follow these instructions and create a new Voting Rights Act. However, even if the Voting Rights Act was a top priority for Congress it would be hard to imagine that it would make it through to Obama's desk without a herculean effort. After today's DOMA ruling, I doubt even the traces of that effort exist anymore.

Sunday, June 3, 2012

Kansas Free From Religious Establishment

I'll get to the second part of my Seattle adventure shortly.

It's now ripe news that Kansas recently passed a law banning Sharia Law (more or less Islamic religious codes) from being used by "courts, administrative agencies or state tribunals," in an apparent attempt to prevent foreign laws from taking over the Kansas democratic system.

This law has been made fun of its fair share of times - one headline reads "Governor Brownback Turns Attention to Non-Problem of Sharia Law." Indeed, the law seems intended to solve a problem that isn't there, as the New York Times iterates:
There are no known cases in which a Kansas judge has based a ruling on Islamic law. But the new law’s supporters have cited a pending divorce case in Sedgwick County in which a man has asked for property to be divided in line with Shariah.
Beyond the obvious fun that can be poked at this new law and its 20 siblings still in state legislatures around the country (including in Arizona, Michigan, and Tennessee, surprise surprise), there is something valuable to be gained from the xenophobia, chiefly in the way the law's writers worded it in order to appear non-discriminatory. The law specifically forbids "courts, administrative agencies and state tribunals [from basing] rulings on any foreign law or legal system that would not grant the same rights guaranteed by the state and federal constitutions." Still, the bill's supporters made it very clear the intention is to stave off the non-existent "infiltration" of Sharia Law.

I wish we could take this law at face value. Forgetting the veiled racism of the intention, I believe the country and each state really should be governed and managed exclusively by the federal and state constitutions. What I see in the law's wording is an attempt to prevent religious establishment, aimed primarily at Islamic establishment but, in its effort to seem non-discriminatory can and should apply to all religious doctrine.

For religiously based doctrine has fed much law making that has deprived American citizens of many rights guaranteed them in the constitution (I'm thinking of women's rights and LGBT rights specifically, among others). After all, what explanation besides a religiously-based one is there for abstinence-only sex education, especially considering that the research that suggests that not only does abstinence-only sex education not prevent teen pregnancies but actually the opposite? What explanation besides a religious one defines marriage as a union between a man and a woman, not to mention all the other rights homosexuals have been deprived of thanks largely to bible passages?

But the juicy thing I really love about this legislation is that in fighting against foreign religious doctrine it also fights against most Christian doctrine. To claim Christianity as American would be amazing folly - the bible is a translated document. Only American-based sects such as Mormonism could legally pass under this law's nose (did Mitt Romney dream up this legislation?). Legal arguments against marriage equality would crumble since equal protection is a protection given the American people under the federal constitution, so revoking one demographic's right to marry would be illegal discrimination. Abstinence-only sex education, the withholding of important health information, would disintegrate as its purpose, to prevent premarital sex (and teen pregnancies, but we've already seen how well that's worked out), has no basis in the constitution and is a biblical-based value - plus, as I've argued before, it's sexist and can therefore be construed, once again, as discrimination.

Now, a supporter of the Kansas law might say that Christianity is not foreign in order to extricate it from the law's grasp. How come it's not foreign? It's explicitly not established as a national religion in the first amendment in the Bill of Rights. If that supporter says it's not foreign because the vast majority of Americans are Christian, then we have yet another case of disenfranchisement of a minority in favor of a majority, the kind of mob rule the federal constitution was expressly designed to protect against. And of course, the constitution does not allow for the establishment of religion even in the event that the majority of its citizens share that religion. In my mind there is no way Kansas courts can allow disturbingly prejudiced legislation fashioned with Christian values in mind to remain legal, thanks to this new law.

Now, I'm getting a little ahead of myself with excitement. This law only applies to "courts, administrative agencies or state tribunals," so it does not prevent the enactment of laws based upon Christian theology. But maybe it will come, a law preventing the enactment of legislation with any basis on "foreign law or legal system that would not grant the same rights guaranteed by the state and federal constitutions." And then Christian lawmakers would be miffed as their destructive pet bills with no constitutional basis get struck down, rightly and legally, for having violated the very law they had championed thanks to their own bigotry.

Oh, their own flaws would be their downfall! It's so poetic! I can't wait!

Friday, May 11, 2012

Religious Does Not Mean Conservative

Barack Obama's announcement that he supports gay marriage, while of course being a political gamble (conservatives have referred to the announcement as a "gift" for Romney), was made with a genius stroke of tact through his appeal to religious voters when he said:
The thing at root that we think about is, not only Christ sacrificing himself on our behalf, but it's also the Golden Rule, you know — treat others the way you would want to be treated.
Now, I am personally disgusted how religion has wormed its way into everyday national politics, and there seem to be daily violations of the First Amendment's establishment clause, including gay marriage bans such as the one recently approved by voters in North Carolina. Policy should not be faith-based since theocracy is inherently limiting to a diverse population, both for those of varied faiths and those within a given faith.

However, I think Obama made the right call when he cited his faith in support of gay marriage because he demonstrated that being a Christian doesn't mean one has to be right wing. Fundamentalist and extreme religious views have been receiving a lot of attention lately thanks to the emergence of the Tea Party, the bizarre candidacy of Rick Santorum and his equally offensive predecessors, the rolling back of women's rights in states, and so on. It has been disheartening to witness the extent the silence of more tempered religious views in the face of outrageous biblical (and in my view unlawful) claims and policy. Yet now, finally, Obama supports gay marriage for reasons that include the bible.

The result? Instead of alienating Christians by pitting a secular, humanist political view against an evangelical Christian one, the debate present within the Christan community concerning biblical interpretation gains momentum. A valuable moderate Christian counterargument to exaggerated homophobic claims is now in the spotlight.

Christianity is not inherently equal to homophobia, sexism, or all the other repressive ideologies espoused by most prominent public Christian figures. Those Christians who don't accept such a repressive, rigid understanding of the bible should be relieved to finally see a political alternative to what we've been witnessing for the duration of the 2012 campaign. And I'll bet there are more moderate Christians than extremists out there. Extreme views, by definition, lay on the extremities.

The next step, I hope, is the slow but definite release of the law from religion's choking grasp.

Sunday, March 11, 2012

The Trouble With Compromise

Could it be that compromise sometimes isn't a cornerstone of how Democracy functions and instead a bane to society?

I was dismayed when I read an article recapping one of the Republican debates a few weeks back when the audience, a vocal force this election season, booed candidates whose record showed a willingness to compromise with the opposition (sadly I can't find the article now). But this anti-compromise sentiment does seem to be the mood of the day. Liberals are upset at Obama for compromising on issues such as, well, just about anything, and Republicans are upset with a compromise on, well, just about anything, it seems. Thankfully we saw an exception recently with the jobs bill, but everyone knows that bipartisanship is a special case nowadays.

Why is it that we value unwavering conviction so highly, especially in today's difficult economic times when unified action could solve major problems? Well, sometimes it seems that compromise actually hurts.

Take the pro-bullying law in Michigan originally intended to be an anti-bullying law. When it was just a bill the law had the intention of preventing children from being intimidated by their peers, a practice that has been known to lead to depression and sometimes violence and suicide. Then the compromise was made: the right added an amendment to the bill that would allow for bullying to continue if in the name of "a sincerely held religious belief or moral conviction." So instead of preventing bullying as originally intended, the bill actually gives legal immunity to any Christians who bully gays in the name of the bible. Previous supporters of the legislation spoke out against its mutated form but to no avail, and now the law is in the books in Michigan.

On the other side of the social political spectrum, we see what happened with the infamous ultra-sound law that just passed in Virginia. Now, before I go on I have to clear something up I wrote about this legislation in an earlier post: the form of this bill that was signed into law allows women seeking an abortion to opt for a traditional ultrasound instead of the vaginal probe technique. On the surface it seems like a good compromise and commendable job by the left in the Virginia legislature to prevent a harmful right-wing law from being too powerful. However, on second glance it becomes apparent that the law now does nothing but burn cash. The reason for the invasive vaginal probe in the first place was to obtain accurate ultrasound images where a normal ultrasound can't in the early stages of pregnancy, when most abortions take place. So in practice the law will mandate a number of costly ultrasounds that will provide no new information. The law's sexist purpose has been defeated, creating a new mandate for doctors to waste money in its place. As Eric Zorn writes in the Chicago Tribune:
The objection here is that when a doctor and a patient agree to such a test, it's a decision made for medical reasons in a clinical context.  When  lawmakers and executive officers compel a doctor to perform such a test for the acknowledged purpose of hoping to dissuade the woman from going through the with abortion, it's not a decision and not a medical procedure, but a political act.  And when that test will reveal absolutely nothing of value, it becomes a charade.
So now all that's left is the "symbolic" expense of the pro-some-life movement, leaving no one happy and everyone worse off. No wonder people are fed up with compromise.

Saturday, March 10, 2012

A Little Solace

If you've been reading my blog lately you probably know that I'm upset with Christians these days. I'm upset at the crazy right-wing Rick Santorum followers for being violently hateful and the moderates and liberals for being apparently unwilling to speak out against it.

Well, perhaps the far right fringe groups of American Christianity has finally gone too far and gotten some of the non-far-right-fringe Christians in an organization called Faithful America to organize a message condemning Tony Perkins' hate speech towards homosexuals and asking why MSNBC continues to provide him with a platform to spread his hate to viewers nationwide. You can see the 30-second ad, which MSNBC refused to air for obvious reasons, below:



It's nice to know there are Christians out there fighting against homophobia. I'm sure there are faith-based reasons to believe in equal rights for everyone regardless of sexual orientation, and if those arguments could only gain publicity then we could avoid the very dangerous prospect of the hateful far right from deciding what "true" Christianity is for Americans, as Rick Santorum is trying to do.

Meanwhile, at Faithful America's site you can read about efforts of not-crazy Christians to combat the right's overwhelming hate furor. You can even sign a petition, their favorite mode of action, if you want.

For me, on the other hand, it's time for bed.

Thursday, March 1, 2012

Freedom To Discriminate

Remember when Herman Cain published an article claiming that Jesus was the original capitalist and concluding that government should abandon the poor?

Remember how Rick Perry claimed that homosexuals should not be allowed to openly serve in the military because it infringes on religious freedoms?

Remember the Michigan anti-bullying law that religious conservatives amended, allowing bullying to continue if the bullies have religious reasons? Remember how they achieved religious exception for bullying gays?

Remember when Rick Santorum told a gay man that his relationship has no intrinsic value to society? Remember how he said women in combat could compromise missions? Remember when he said that millions of Americans, including President Obama, aren't really Christians because there's no such thing as a liberal Christian?

Remember how the Virginia state legislature passed legislation requiring women who want an abortion to look at an ultrasound of the fetus first, an ultrasound only obtainable in most cases by probing women's vaginas, in order to preserve the "sanctity of life"? In other words, legalized violation similar to rape?

Remember how some pharmacists refuse to sell the morning after pill to rape victims because they're so pro-life? And others who won't sell birth control at all?

Remember when legislature was proposed in Georgia that would make it illegal to have a miscarriage?

Remember when Prop 8 passed in California in 2008, still in the courts today and still denying rights to same sex couples?

Attention social conservatives:

The religious right is not fighting for the right to free religious practice. It is fighting for the right to discriminate against other in the name of religious practice. The right to establish and practice religion as specified in the first amendment does not give the right to persecute others with religious freedom as the excuse. It does not give you the right to do whatever you want simply because you are religious.

Thursday, February 9, 2012

Bullying Is Bad

It's something we learn when we're children, running home in tears after being cornered by the big kids, jostled around, called names, threatened for our differences - either interpreted or blatant - jeered at, made to force back our tears. It is said that everyone had a bully growing up, and if you can't remember his name it was probably you (unless you're a weird loner kid like I was, who mildly participated on either side off and on). It feels horrible to be bullied, and the easiest reaction to succumb to is that of revenge.

We can see a prime example of grown men engaging in this juvenile behavior that, I'm becoming more and more convinced, is one of the most difficult habits to grow out of. First, we have popular sex advice columnist and LGBTQ activist Dan Savage, of whom I am an unashamed fan, who famously redefined Rick Santorum's last name as a disgusting reference to anal sex in 2003; luckily for the now current presidential candidate because of his inexplicable success in the Republican primary yesterday, that definition is no longer the first result when you enter his name into Google. Explaining why he did it (to Santorum and not other politicians who hurt the LGBTQ cause, such as Obama), Dan Savage says:
It was Santorum equating loving, committed same-sex relationships with dog f***ing and child rape... Santorum argued in favor of states being allowed to arrest, prosecute, and imprison Americans—gay and straight—for private, consensual, adult sexual conduct. Santorum cemented our enmity when he went on to compare gay relationships to incest and Islamic terrorism.
I can read the pain in Savage's words here, and I can't blame him, someone being bullied to such an extreme - even more than bullied: denied basic civil rights - just "for the way he loves." The same pain is evident in his recurring blog post theme "O They Will Know We Are Christians When..." where he vilifies the Christians who vilify homosexuals.

But along with the pain there is a toxic hatred, and the bullying has reversed course. Savage himself writes like an insecure bully, and his prank on Rick Santorum is comparable to cyber bullying. Now we have two bullies - Santorum and Savage - fighting their hateful battle on the national stage with rights and legislation on the line. Christians and Republicans who support the LGBTQ cause feel alienated by Savage's hate, and moderate right-wingers who want smaller government are alienated by Santorum's righteous hate. And as the nationwide bullying epidemic increases, the country bears witness to speeches like this one, riddled with groundless hatred:



And the result? Polarization. Is it any wonder a moderate president like Barack Obama could be ridiculed as a godless Socialist by Republicans and a right-wing Republican in disguise by progressives at the same time? There's no room for moderation in a battleground of intimidation and fear.

Of course it's not just Rick Santorum and Dan Savage who perpetrate bullying (remember this charming video from Rick Perry?). But it's a pertinent example because Savage often voices support for anti-bullying legislation to protect gay children in schools, while Santorum feels for some reason I can't quite fathom that Obama is doing all he can to destroy God in America, as the video above shows.

How can two people be so vehemently against bullying while being such bullies themselves? No self-respecting teacher would allow such behavior in the classroom, so why is it politics as usual?

This endless cycle of hurt and pained revenge doesn't have to continue. We don't have to put up with such bigotry, both on the right and the left. I don't want to live in a country where the side that bullies best gets the rights and protections of law. If we truly want a country where we coexist and work together for a better future, the America that belongs to everyone as I learned about in school, we cannot tolerate this blatant manipulation of bigotry and bully tactics to gain power and influence. There will always be repression and discrimination as long as the bigots and bullies, the very people the Constitution was written to protect us from, run our country.

But most importantly of all: Don't hate! Don't hate Republicans, Liberals, Muslims, homosexuals, fundamentalists, Jews, or even other hateful people. Don't respond to hatred with more hatred, or else you will have become the very thing you hated in the first place! And if that happens America will become a country of slaves to avarice, oppression, and injustice.

I would like to leave you all with a beautiful story read on the Moth by Ernesto Quiñonez about the dangers of bullying based on his experiences growing up in Spanish Harlem. Surviving from his own pained and hateful lashing out, he says:
Prejudice is so evil that it can creep up on you, and before you know it you yourself have become the bigot.
Please listen to it here. It's one of the best uses of 12 minutes I can think of.

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Not The Gays' Fault

It turns out the "threat to marriage" is a quite nuanced. According to a recent report, new marriages have dropped by 5% - in other words, people aren't getting married in as large a number as they used to. Many people are now staying single, living with their partner without marrying, remaining widowed, or are separated. In fact, the number of married people in America is so low that it's almost not even a majority anymore. As Stephanie Coontz, a family life historian at Evergreen State College says:
"...we can no longer pretend that marriage is the central organizing principle of society. We have to take account of the many, many social networks and relationships that people cycle through, marriage being just one of them." (Source: NPR News)

(Source: NPR News via Pew Research Center)

So what is the cause of this decline? Why is it that people aren't lined up to be married like they used to? What exactly is threatening this o most sacred of sacred institutions? Surely our bigoted presidential candidates Rick Santorum, Rick Perry, Michelle Bachmann, Newt Gingrich, and Mitt Romney would say it has something to do with Don't Ask, Don't Tell being repealed. But surprisingly - by which I mean "to nobody's surprise" - the lower marriage rates have nothing to do with homosexuality.

One non-gay reason people aren't getting married is simply that times are changing. For example, folks younger than 30 (my age group!) are getting married only 20% of the time compared to fifty years ago when it was 60%. My parents got married when they were 22 - I'm 23 and plan to be unmarried for years to come. I've had many a conversation with young'uns my age who are in the same boat: having reached the age their parents were when they married, we get a little freaked out that we, at this unstable phase of our lives where we don't have careers or even firmed-up plans, could be settling down and starting families.

This brings me to the most non-gay factor of all for these low marriage rates: the economy. People of marriageable age are less likely get married because they aren't in a stable enough situation to start a family. Jobs are hard to find, and good jobs even harder, especially for those who don't have graduate degrees (which require more years to delay attaining a career). Speaking of the economy, here's some food for thought: there's a distinct "marriage gap" between the rich and the poor. Wealthy people are much more likely to get married than working class people without college degrees. The threat to marriage, as it turns out, is "yet another consequence of the nation's widening economic inequality" (NPR News).

Very not-gay.

Not long after many huge multi-national corporations including Google, Microsoft, Levi, Nike, and CBS told a federal court that DOMA (the Defense Of Marriage Act) is bad for business, we learn that unregulated business, the cause of our crappy economy, is actually bad for marriage. Now, I'm not very sentimental about marriage and I believe LGBTQ activists could have other objectives - such as bully prevention, obtaining hospital visitation rights, and securing equal opportunity employment. On the other hand, I'm sick of fundamentalists blaming the gays for the destruction of family values when every indicator points to other factors. If preserving marriage is really a priority for fundamentalists (which I don't believe it should, but what do I know?), then what they need to do is fix the economy and close the gap between the rich and the poor. That would be a much better method for protecting marriage than bigoted discrimination.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Not Just The Party Of No

It's a common belief that, to solidify power over people, there needs to be a common enemy. After 9/11 that enemy became the loosely-defined "terrorists," but it hasn't always been that way. Naomi Klein persuasively argues in Shock Doctrine that neo-liberal economics - the theory that government regulation of any kind is harmful to the economy, a theory that has resulted in the economic ruin of developing nations in Latin America, Africa, and Asia - could not have succeeded without outside threats. One example she cites is former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher's breaking of labor unions and abolishing rent controls, something she believed at the beginning of her term to be impossible in a democracy. But once she added a perceived threat, in this case war in a British territory, democratic process was put on hold, and amid the confusion of British citizens was able to enact her radical and harmful economic policies.

This long held tradition of "othering" in order to gain power would, of course, not cease in the 21st century. And here we turn to the current Republican party and one of the most offensive campaign ads I've ever seen (and I've seen this one):

The Republican Party is no longer simply the party of no, doing everything it can to make the Democrats look incompetent and then blame them for not accomplishing anything - a formidable strategy. We saw them after 9/11 become the party of fear, taking away our 4th amendment rights in the name of national security, spying on us, and throwing us into indefinite wars with irrelevant nations despite warnings from the international community and the UN. Basically, 9/11 allowed the government to circumvent the law momentarily.

Well, the momentary chaos is over and fear mongering, while still effective, isn't working quite like it used to. "Othering" terrorists, Middle Easterners, and Muslims isn't enough anymore. So they have turned to Americans themselves, completing the transition into a full-fledged Party of Hate. In Rick Perry's ad, which hardly stands alone, the target of their hate is homosexuality. A staple for religious fundamentalists, denying rights to homosexuals has long been on the conservative agenda. Now, many gay rights activists wonder why conservatives would focus so intently on the sin of homosexuality while ignoring other strange biblical decrees given the same emphasis in the text, such as stoning adulterers or not wearing clothing made from more than one material. Others wonder why the party of "family values" is riddled with sex scandals (in both the straight and gay varieties). So who are these people to deny gay rights? They're hateful breeders of hate, plain and simple. If we hate gay people enough, people like Rick Perry reason, then there's a chance we might forget reason and actually vote for people like Rick Perry.

And thanks to all that hatred, another gay teenager has committed suicide because of bullying. The hate-mongering is working, folks.

The other major target of Republican hatred (besides Democrats, Socialists, Liberals, Immigrants, and Communists) is, as I've said many times, the poor. And, by extension, Occupy Wall Street.

So say "so long" to the party of "no" and the party of "fear." Now we can expect a reign of hatred and intolerance should one of the Republican candidates take the White House next year. Happy holidays.